Manchester Derby VAR Error Caused by 'Tunnel Vision', Says Pro Ref Chief

Howard Webb, chief refereeing officer for Pro Ref, the body responsible for officiating in English professional football, has attributed the incorrect VAR decision that allowed Erling Haaland's goal in Sunday's Manchester derby to 'tunnel vision' by the officials. Webb expressed his deep disappointment with the outcome, highlighting that the error stemmed from an excessive focus during the review.

Highlights

• Howard Webb stated that Pro Ref was 'really disappointed' with the VAR decision.
• The error occurred because VAR officials became overly focused on Haaland's position, failing to properly assess teammate Enzo Fernandez's offside involvement.
• Haaland's goal was initially disallowed for offside but was then permitted after a VAR review.
• Pro Ref later acknowledged the goal should not have been awarded and communicated the error to Manchester United.
• VAR officials Matt Donohue and assistant VAR Blake Antrobus will not officiate until after the international break.

Details

Erling Haaland's second-half strike for Manchester City against Manchester United was initially ruled out for offside. However, following a VAR review, the goal was allowed to stand. Pro Ref subsequently confirmed that the goal should not have been awarded, as VAR failed to adequately consider the involvement of teammate Enzo Fernandez, who attempted to play the ball from an offside position.

Speaking on 'Match Officials Mic’d Up' on Sky Sports and TNT Sports, Howard Webb said, "I was really disappointed with this outcome. We all are. None more so than the officials themselves." Webb explained that while the semi-automated offside system quickly confirmed Haaland was onside, the VAR official developed 'tunnel vision' and did not fully evaluate Fernandez's impact on the play.

Manchester United manager Michael Carrick criticized the decision after his side's 1-0 home defeat. While VAR is designed by FIFA to check, review, and correct clear and obvious errors, it continues to be a contentious topic in football discussions.

Why it matters

This incident once again brings to the forefront the debate surrounding the correct application of VAR in football and the crucial role of human judgment in refereeing decisions. Errors in major derbies can significantly impact not only the match result but also league standings and team morale. Pro Ref's acknowledgment of the mistake and the temporary removal of the involved officials are seen as important steps towards transparency.